Have you ever had a brilliant business idea, only to discover years later that someone else has beaten you to market? If you are a professional athlete, you might break your hand punching a fire extinguisher or picture frame in frustration. If you are a web developer, you might indignantly exclaim, “They literally stole
Which Statute of Limitations Applies to Your Declaratory Judgment Action?
So your client wants you to file a declaratory judgment action, but you are unsure of whether the applicable statute of limitations has expired. But what is the applicable statute of limitations in a declaratory judgment action? Since there is no limitations period specifically addressed to the declaratory judgment action, it generally falls under the…
Be Sure to ‘Like’ This Summons on Facebook
My colleague Adam Rafsky’s astute post last week on Manhattan Commercial Division Justice Shirley Werner Kornreich’s recent reminder regarding the importance of proper service and claim viability when seeking a default judgment under CPLR 3215 reminded me of another default decision last fall from the same judge also addressing issues of service.

In Wimbeldon Fin. …
Defamation Claims Against Gemological Institute Doomed: Qualified Privilege Shield Is Stronger Than A Diamond
“Diamonds are nothing more than chunks of coal that stuck to their jobs,” said Malcom Forbes. An industry that generates over $13 billion annually, diamonds are considered one of the world’s major natural resources. Critical to the integrity of the market are reports or certificates that grade the quality of the stones…
A Reminder for Non-Resident Attorneys Seeking to Practice in New York: Be Sure to Comply with Judiciary Law § 470!
This week, we examine the answer to a simple question: may an out-of-state lawyer serve as counsel in a New York state court procee
ding absent making a motion for admission pro hac vice? To answer this slightly ambiguously worded question, we need more information. Specifically, the answer depends on the meaning of “out-of-state”…
Check the Rules Part IV
In one of our very first posts on this blog – entitled “First Things First: Check the Rules!” – we reported on some updates in March of this year to Manhattan Commercial Division Justice Eileen Bransten’s individual practice rules. We took the opportunity then to remind Commercial Division practitioners, in light of the…
Proposed Amendment to Commercial Division Rule 11-g Seeks to Add Clawback Language to Standard Confidentiality Order
Disclosure of Electronically Stored Information (“ESI”) has become a staple in commercial cases. Of course, with the vast number of documents and ESI being reviewed and the increased complexity in the review process, the risk of inadvertent production of privileged information is at its highest. The inadvertent production of privileged material often leads to lengthy,…
Attorneys Switching Sides During Litigation Sometimes Allowed… at least in the First Department!
Notwithstanding general public opinion of attorney ethics, most people (including attorneys) believe that an attorney cannot dump a client in the middle of litigation to represent the other side. However, attorneys in the First Department may be surprised to learn that, in certain circumstances, a representation adverse to their former clients, even in litigation arising…
Is it a Privilege to Speak With a PR Consultant? Maybe Not for Kesha!
So you were just retained on what could become a high-profile case. The stakes are high, and it’s unclear how this will play in the media. The issue may arise based on the parties to the case, the nature of the claims, or both. Either way, as part of your litigation strategy, you decide that…
Golf, the Commercial Division, and Expert Disclosure: No Sandbaggers Allowed!
“The expert discovery rules are promulgated so no party will be ‘sandbagged’ or surprised by another expert’s opinion” – Manhattan Commercial Division Justice Eileen Bransten
Several weeks ago, we reviewed some of the newer Commercial Division Rules and reported on a couple of recent decisions from Justice Shirley Werner Korneich of the Manhattan Commercial…